Cuisenaire Rods are brightly colored wooden sticks. Technically, they’re “proportionally sized rectangular parallelepipeds.” (But only say that if you want to hear your 3 year old repeat something really cute!)
The “proportional” thing is important. The white ones are 1cm square, the red ones are twice as long and each color is 1cm more than the next color.
I’m anticipating many articles and videos on how to teach with these (since the possibilities with these things are virtually unlimited), so I thought I would start a running series. Here are the ideas and the links to the articles/videos that are ready:
Cuisenaire Rods – (this one) graphing and practicing coordinate pairs (see video below)
Most parents aren’t professional mathematicians. But there are a few. This is the second in a series of interviews with mathematician parents with the goal of helping parents integrate math teaching into parenting.
I had the privilege of interviewing Caroline Mukisa, a math teacher and math blogger.
MathFour: Thanks for taking the time to chat, Caroline. First, what’s your degree and career? And how long have you been in math?
I’ve a Bachelors in Civil Engineering from Imperial College, University of London and a Post Graduate Certificate in Maths Education from Cambridge University. I taught maths to high school students in the UK, and I also ran a Kumon tuition centre before moving to the Middle East as an expat. I now run the Maths Insider website. My husband has a Bachelors in Maths also from Imperial and a Masters in Mathematical Modeling from Oxford University.
MathFour: Tell me about your family – how many kids do you have and how old are they? Are any of them more or less interested in math than the others?
Caroline: I’ve got four kids aged 11, 10, 4 and 2. My 10 year old son is very much the maths boffin, he’s memorized the first 300 digits of pi just for fun. His 11 year old sister is more of a problem solver. The younger two like counting and sorting but it’s too early to say if they’ve caught the maths bug yet!
MathFour: Do you have any worries about your children academically? In particular, do you think they will do better in math than in other subjects because of your influence?
Caroline: With maths, being a former maths teacher, I have a feel of how they’re each doing with that subject, whereas with the other subjects, it’s difficult to judge. For example, “Is that poem they wrote good for their age level?”
MathFour: How do you play with your kids? In particular, what kind of math play do you do compared with non-math play?
Caroline: We talk a lot about maths, we like showing them You Tube videos or Ted Talks related to maths or science, but we also try to expose them to different things like poetry, anthropology, and business.
MathFour: Do you think you speak with your children or behave differently than other parents because you have a math background?
Caroline: I’m not sure about that. I don’t talk about maths with my kids in front of other parents – I don’t want to appear to be “showing off” although my 10 yr old likes to “perform maths.”
MathFour: Have you ever had any of your children express negative thoughts about math and how did you handle it?
Caroline: Of course! There’s always days when maths homework is not appreciated, and although my 11 year old finds maths easy, I wouldn’t say she loves it – she likes that maths can help her do the things she likes, like Design and Technology and Science. It’s not a problem – kids shouldn’t be carbon copies of their parents.
MathFour: How is the interaction with your children’s math teachers?
Caroline: I usually let my kids teachers know early on about my and my husband’s maths background. We try to work with the kids teachers to help extend their maths but in the end we can supplement and support their maths ourselves at home.
MathFour: Now to change direction a little to a more worldview of math. What do you see as the biggest challenge in math education today?
Caroline: With the move away from rote learning towards practical maths, kids mental maths skills are declining. Parents need to make sure that they’re reinforcing those skills at home, since there’s not enough time allocated to fully learning them within the curriculum.
MathFour: What do you see great happening in the world of math education?
Caroline: I love that kids get to explore different practical applications of maths, with many teachers, using technology to present real-life math problems.
MathFour: What advice can you give to non-mathematician parents that might help them raise their kids to like and appreciate math.
Caroline: I think the key things are to stay positive about maths even if you hate it, try to spot something related to maths as often as you can. If your child is having problems with maths, act early and make sure their basic skills are solid. And of course, read MathFour and Maths Insider!
MathFour: Thanks so much for taking the time to answer our questions, Caroline!
How about you? Do you have any questions for a mathematician parent? Share them in the comments – I’ll bet Caroline will be around to answer them!
I started this series over a month ago. In that time, I’ve gotten pretty deep in thinking, learning and reading about the order of operations. I’ve seen a variety of ways people view, use and teach it.
Before I go too far into some conclusions, though, let’s look at addition and subtraction.
Consider the problem . Moving from left to right, and doing both subtraction and addition as we come to them, we get 4. If we found a book, or person, that meant the full-on PEMDAS and wanted addition done strictly before subtraction, then we would end up with 0. The latter is because we would do the addition of 3 and 2 before we did the subtraction.
Which is right?
It depends on what you really mean. If you don’t know if you should go left to right or strictly addition before subtraction, either look in the textbook you’re using or demand parenthesis.
The text will clearly outline the order of operations it’s following. Be careful, too because there isn’t always agreement among textbooks. I have seen some texts that instruct the learner to do multiplication first and then go back and do all the division signs. While others (and this is more common, today) have us do multiplication and division from left to right, simultaneously.
If you compare contemporary texts to each other, you’re likely to find them all the same. But grab a math text from the 80s at Half Priced Books. I’ll bet you’ll find at least 50% of the time they put division strictly after multiplication. (I’ll verify this the next time I’m there.)
The order of operations needs context.
I have $5 in my bank account. Then I bought a coffee for $3 and a bagel for $2. I might accidentally write down . I still mean, “I need to add up the stuff I spent and subtract it from my balance.” I wrote it in error, though. What’s “mathematically” correct is .
But you knew what I meant.
This was a typo that was helped along by using the context.
Until there’s a reason to do arithmetic, the order in which we do things is arbitrary. If we all agreed to do addition first, then multiplication, we would calculate and come up with 35 (instead of 23).
As long as we all come up with the same thing, we’re fine.
“We” have agreed to do multiplication things before we do addition things. So “we” would come up with 23 in the example.
Coach G noted it correctly: the order of operations is a convention. In other words, we’ve decided on it. We invented it.
How can you use this to teach your children?
The coolest thing is that you can let them play. Get dirty. Break it.
Remember opposite day? Have that. Let your little one make new rules. Let them see what happens if you all decide one day to do multiplication before addition. If your child is older and doing some algebra, this will mean reversing the order in which you UNDO the operations too!
This is a real brain stretcher. But it’s just math. You’re not building a bridge or balancing your checkbook. Let them break it. Let them see what happens if you make your own rules.
And then they’ll really learn!
Let me know how it goes – share your stories in the comments.
Last week’s article on the order of operations included a quick mention that division is the same as multiplication – but different. Now’s the time to explain that a bit.
The only thing mathematicians like to do more than create, is destroy. That’s how we get imaginary numbers, dividing by zero and raising things to infinity.
Once we create with multiplication, we want to know what happens when we destroy with the opposite of multiplication.
Enter Division, stage right.
Multiplication is created from the need to quickly add a bunch of numbers that are all the same. They each must be equal to make this work:
6 + 6 + 6 + 6 + 6 is shortcutted to 5 X 6.
Division is the breaking up into pieces that are all equal.
Technically we can break 30 up into these 5 pieces: 4, 8, 7, 6 and 5. But “division” requires (or implies) that we are dividing equally. So 30 would have to be broken up into 5 equal pieces of 6 each.
Of course this is in a purely mathematical world. When you get into a toddler world, things will be different.
How division is the same as multiplication.
We represents multiplication with little x‘s or dots or stars. Like this:
3 X 5 or 3 • 5 or 3 * 5
We represent division with this cute little symbol:
But we can write it in many more ways. Notice the cute symbol looks like a fraction with dots on the top and bottom. That’s not a coincidence. A fraction means division.
is the same as .
Remember the poem:
When dividing fractions Don’t bat an eye Just flip the last And multiply!
Well, you can change this to:
When dividing numbers Don’t bat an eye Just flip the last And multiply!
And “flipping” the last just means taking the “assumed 1” that’s underneath it and putting it on the top.
Now go forth and divide…
So when you’re teaching the MD in PEMDAS, the order of operations, remember that D is the same as M. And if things get a little confusing, demand some parenthesis before doing the problem.
The Order of Operations can be boiled down into three “real” operations.
Parenthesis are merely a way to group things – they aren’t a real operation. So they doesn’t count as a real operation.
Since division is really just multiplication turned upside down, we don’t need to include it separately, either. Likewise, subtraction is addition on its ear. So we throw him out, too.
Now we have only three: exponents, multiplication and addition.
You see that 3 x 3 x 3 x 3 is 34. The exponent is the shortcut for multiplication.
Multiplication is the shortcut for addition.
Likewise, when we get overwhelmed with adding up the same numbers over and over, like in the video, 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4, we can use multiplication to shortcut it: 5 x 4.
Follow the shortcut evolution.
The shortcut evolution is like this
Addition came first.
Then we created multiplication to make addition easier.
Then we created exponents to make multiplication easier.
So when you do arithmetic, we should do the “recent” shortcuts first (exponents) and then the “older” shortcuts (multiplication) and then the “regular” arithmetic (addition). Remember that subtraction is addition and division is multiplication.
And keep in mind that we need to watch the grouping or anything isolated with parenthesis, absolute value bars or in a fraction. The grouping/isolation tools always trump the other operation rules.
What if your answer isn’t the same as the back of the book?
Some textbooks actually have multiplication done before division. This means that the problem 9 ÷ 3 x 2 will show a different answer (3/2) in that textbook’s solution pages than what you would get following the OoO I’m describing here (6). These texts are rare, but I’ve seen them. So keep your eyes peeled.
The Order of Operations is a set of rules that we’ve agreed on. Which means that as long as a textbook clearly defines their order that they will follow, they can do things like this.
If you get confused as to which to do first, demand parenthesis. (Yes, you can do that.) Or put parenthesis into your child’s textbook to help them out.
The problem sets should be there to enforce, not confuse.
What do you think? Does this help or hinder the way you’ve always viewed the Order of Operations? Share your thoughts in the comments.
In the order of operations, the “Exponents” rule represents a bunch more than just superscripts or tiny numbers flying up and to the right of things.
Roots are exponents, too!
Tree Roots by Linda Allardice
Not the ones from trees, but things like square roots and cube roots. Consider . You do the square root first because it qualified as an “exponent.”
But if you had , the 9 + 2 is under the radical sign (the square root sign) so it’s bound together in the “Parenthesis” rule.
This one isn’t that hard with arithmetic, but when you come to algebra and start “undoing” these things – it’s important to remember that roots fall into this category.
Fractional exponents are exponents.
This one seems pretty “duh” so it’s easy to see how they fall into the “E” of the order of operations. But what are fractional exponents really?
So fractional exponents are the same as roots.
Note that some fractional exponents are roots and “plain” exponents all mixed up. Like this one:
This is a big fat full concept that needs a little more explaining. I’ll write more on these in another article.
Logs fall under the E.
Axe In Stump by caroline steinhauer
As my algebra and computer math teacher in high school, Mrs. Kelley, used to tell us – logarithms are exponents. It took me a long time to figure out what the heck she meant. But when I did, I thought it was brilliant.
Notice who the exponent is in this: 32 = 9: 2 is the exponent. And 2 is the same as because the equals sign in means “is the same as.” So the logarithm is the exponent 2.
Still with me? Either way, it’s okay. It’s a weird concept that I can go into detail in a video soon.
The thing to remember here is that logarithms fall into the “Exponents” rule of the order of operations.
So if you have , you have to do the first and then add the 7 after.
Want more on exponents?
In the meantime, you can check out more than everything you always wanted to know about exponents on the Wikipedia Exponents page. Rebecca Zook created a great video on logarithms. And check out this explanation and problems to work on fractional exponents.
And let me know what you think. Did I miss something?
I mentioned in the introductory article for this series that “the order of operations isn’t best practice for expressions involving variables.”
When you involve a variable, you can’t just “do” the arithmetic. Like in the case of 2(3x + 4)=11. You can’t add 3x and 4 to get a result before moving on. You have to use the distributive property.
And even the distributive property won’t work sometimes – as in the case of absolute values shown below.
Parenthesis mean isolation.
When we say “parenthesis” in the Order of Operations (OoO for short), we mean anything that’s grouped together and isolated. This could mean with actual parenthesis. This could mean [square brackets] or {curly brackets}.
Although grownups seem to know that square and curly brackets are the equivalent of parenthesis, children don’t. This has to be said out loud.
“Parenthesis” in the OoO can also mean |absolute value bars|. This one’s not so clear.
When you try to solve the equation 4|2x+3|=20, you have to start with dividing by 4 to isolate the absolute value chunk. There’s not a “rule” for distributing the 4.
(Although, it would be worth it, and fun, to see if your children can come up with some rules for distributing within absolute value bars. This would be some real mathematics at work for them – experimenting and discovering.)
Tops and bottoms of fractions are implied parenthesis.
It’s also the case that the numerator (top) and denominator (bottom) of a fraction are isolated places. These fall under the OoO as parenthesis.
Check out this older video I did. It shows how this works with fractions:
Parenthesis are for deviation from the other rules.
David Chandler of Math without Borders commented this in the previous article of this series:
The rule is to do higher level operations first. Use parentheses whenever your intention is to deviate from this rule.
If you can focus on this instead of a mnemonic device, you can get students to internalize what’s going on with the OoO. It’s important, however, to make sure they remember about other bracket shapes as well as isolation.
Let us know your tips and thoughts on the P in PEMDAS!
The Order of Operations (OoO for short) is used everywhere in mathematics because it encompasses many of the foundational rules that we’ve agreed to follow.
Alas, students have been given the cheap and dirty version of it for years. “Here, memorize this thing about your Dear Aunt Sally!” What the heck?!
There are subtleties in the Order of Operations that every person over the age of seven should know.
The series begins today.
The order of operations is a set of rules – like the drivers’ handbook for math. If everyone follows the rules, we’ll all be safe. But if someone makes a bad turn, we could be looking at a crash.
But the Order of Operations is only a set of rules for arithmetic! It isn’t even the best practice when it comes to expressions involving a variable like x. I’ll cover what I mean in this weekly series.
Here are the proposed articles:
Intro and mnemonics
Parenthesis
Exponents
Exponents, Multiplication and Addition
Multiplication and Division
Addition, Subtraction and Conclusions
Exponents of Negative Numbers
Another Reason to Ban PEMDAS (aka parenthesis aren’t an operation)
Mnemonics for PEMDAS
Well, there’s one: PEMDAS (pronounced just like it looks). That’s what the cool kids in high school always said. It was the same kids who said “soh-cah-toa” – which I thought sounded really goofy.
And then there’s “Please Excuse My Dear Aunt Sally.” And of course “Piranhas Eat Mostly Decayed Antelope Skin.”